Skip to content

Is Evidence-based Psychiatry Ethical?, by Mona Gupta

12/08/2014


Recent debates about antidepressants probe three possible explanations for the effectiveness of these medications: They are effective because their active component has specific and targeted psychodynamic action (this is most commercially interesting claim), the placebo effect is responsible for the medications’ effectiveness, or the drugs involve some unknown mechanism of action that provokes a nonspecific altered mental state alongside with a placebo effect (Gupta 2014, 59). 
The psychiatrist and bioethicist Mona Gupta notes, “All three interpretations are plausible, but none is self-evidently true or false” (59).


Now, if that is the case, then the psychiatric community has the prerogative to determine which is most likely. Professional and financial interests tend to balance the choice toward the first explanation, which presupposes specific antidepressant effectiveness.

Vidal, Fernando and Ortega, Francisco. Being Brains: Making the Cerebral Subject (Forms of Living)....

Description

Rated as one of the top 15 breakthroughs in medicine over the last 150 years, evidence-based medicine (EBM) has become highly influential in medicine. Put simply, EBM promotes a seemingly irrefutable, principle: that decision-making in medical practice should be based, as much as possible, on the most up-to-date research findings. EBM has been particularly popular within psychiatry, a field that is haunted by a legacy of controversial interventions. For advocates, anchoring psychiatric practice in research data makes psychiatry more scientific valid and ethically legitimate. Few, however, have questioned whether EBM, a concept pioneered by those working in other areas of medicine, can be applied to psychiatric disorders.

In this groundbreaking book, the Canadian psychiatrist and ethicist Mona Gupta analyzes the basic assumptions of EBM, and critically examines their applicability to psychiatry. By highlighting the basic ethical tensions between psychiatry and EBM, the author addresses the fundamental and controversial question - should psychiatrists practice evidence-based medicine at all?

Find the book at the website for Oxford University Press:

Is Evidence-based Psychiatry Ethical?

In the lecture below, Mona Gupta offers an overview of her book:In the lecture below, Mona Gupta offers an overview of her book:
Mona Gupta, M.D., C. M., FRCPC, Ph.D. Is Evidence Based Psychiatry Ethical

0 comments

Comment

No comments avaliable.

Author

Tags

Info

Published in 30/01/2019

Updated in 19/02/2021

All events in the topic Chap. 3: Cerebralizing Distress:


01/09/2007 (Aprox)Can Neuroscience be integrated into the DSM-V?, by Steven HymanCan Neuroscience be integrated into the DSM-V?, by Steven Hyman
02/01/2011 (Aprox)The Pharma-Psych NexusThe Pharma-Psych Nexus
01/01/1997 (Aprox)01/01/2013 (Aprox)Books by David HealyBooks by David Healy
01/12/1951 (Aprox)Synthetization of ChlorpromazineSynthetization of Chlorpromazine
12/08/2014Is Evidence-based Psychiatry Ethical?, by Mona Gupta
03/01/2007 (Aprox)Global Mental Health Movement (GMH)
01/01/2008 (Aprox)Mental Health Gap Action Programme (mhGAP)
01/01/2002 (Aprox)01/01/2013 (Aprox)Globalization of PsychiatryGlobalization of Psychiatry
01/01/2001 (Aprox)World Health ReportWorld Health Report
03/01/2005 (Aprox)The bio-bio-bio model of madness, by John ReadThe bio-bio-bio model of madness, by John Read
01/03/2012 (Aprox)The Epigenetics Revolution, by Nessa CareyThe Epigenetics Revolution, by Nessa Carey
01/01/2010 (Aprox)Major Depressive Disorder: 2nd leading cause of disability worldwideMajor Depressive Disorder: 2nd leading cause of disability worldwide
01/01/2011 (Aprox)The pharmaceutical industry's turn: from medication to geneticsThe pharmaceutical industry's turn: from medication to genetics
10/07/2014Most recent edition of the Handbook of DepressionMost recent edition of the Handbook of Depression
01/07/2000 (Aprox)Nosologomania: A Disorder of Psychiatry, by Herman van PraagNosologomania: A Disorder of Psychiatry, by Herman van Praag
15/09/2014Melancholia: The Western Malady, by Matthew BellMelancholia: The Western Malady, by Matthew Bell
18/10/2005Can Brain Scans See Depression?, by Benedict CareyCan Brain Scans See Depression?, by Benedict Carey
03/01/2008 (Aprox)Biological Vulnerability of Depression, by Nantel-Vivier and PihlBiological Vulnerability of Depression, by Nantel-Vivier and Pihl
02/01/2002 (Aprox)Functional Neuroimaging of Depression, by Erk, Walter and SpitzerFunctional Neuroimaging of Depression, by Erk, Walter and Spitzer
01/02/2002 (Aprox)Depression: Perspectives from Affective Neuroscience, by Davidson et al.Depression: Perspectives from Affective Neuroscience, by Davidson et al.
02/01/2014 (Aprox)The Neurobiology of Meditation and Mindfulness, by Tobias EschThe Neurobiology of Meditation and Mindfulness, by Tobias Esch
20/09/2013Concentrating on Kindness, an article on Science MagConcentrating on Kindness, an article on Science Mag
02/01/2009 (Aprox)Lack of evidence of causality in depressionLack of evidence of causality in depression
02/01/2013 (Aprox)Classification of Depressive Disorders, by Philip J. CowenClassification of Depressive Disorders, by Philip J. Cowen
03/01/2013 (Aprox)The search for treatment-specific biomarkersThe search for treatment-specific biomarkers
04/01/2013 (Aprox)Hopes for diagnostic based on identified biomarkers
16/01/2001A Default Mode of Brain Function, by Raichle et al.A Default Mode of Brain Function, by Raichle et al.
03/01/1998 (Aprox)Thoughts on Finding Myself Differently Brained, by Jane MeyerdingThoughts on Finding Myself Differently Brained, by Jane Meyerding
02/01/1999 (Aprox)Why Can’t You Be Normal for Once in Your Life? by Judy SingerWhy Can’t You Be Normal for Once in Your Life? by Judy Singer
01/01/1998 (Aprox)NeurodiversityNeurodiversity
01/01/1940 (Aprox)01/01/1975 (Aprox)Influence of psychoanalytic explanationsInfluence of psychoanalytic explanations
01/01/1960 (Aprox)The Divided Self, by Ronald LaingThe Divided Self, by Ronald Laing
01/01/1967 (Aprox)Psychiatry and Anti-Psychiatry, by David CooperPsychiatry and Anti-Psychiatry, by David Cooper
01/03/1973 (Aprox)Mental Patients' UnionMental Patients' Union
01/01/1962 (Aprox)National Autistic SocietyNational Autistic Society
01/01/1965 (Aprox)Autism Society of AmericaAutism Society of America
01/01/1990 (Aprox)The rise of Internet
01/01/1992 (Aprox)01/01/1996 (Aprox)Autism Network InternationalAutism Network International
01/01/1994 (Aprox)National Alliance for Autism ResearchNational Alliance for Autism Research
03/01/1995 (Aprox)Cure Autism Now FoundationCure Autism Now Foundation
18/11/2004Petition to the United Nations
02/01/1995 (Aprox)Thinking in Pictures, by Temple GrandinThinking in Pictures, by Temple Grandin
01/01/2005 (Aprox)Acceptance Versus Cure, by Sue RubinAcceptance Versus Cure, by Sue Rubin
18/07/2005First Autistic Pride DayFirst Autistic Pride Day
02/01/2005 (Aprox)A Mother's Perspective, by Kit Weintraub
01/01/1999 (Aprox)Why I Dislike 'Person First' Language, by Jim Sinclair
01/01/1995 (Aprox)The Looping Effects of Human Kinds, by Ian HackingThe Looping Effects of Human Kinds, by Ian Hacking
02/01/2006 (Aprox)On Our Own Terms: Emerging Autistic Culture, by Martijn DekkerOn Our Own Terms: Emerging Autistic Culture, by Martijn Dekker
01/01/1997 (Aprox)Autism Genetic Resource ExchangeAutism Genetic Resource Exchange
01/01/2006 (Aprox)Voices From The Spectrum, by Ariel and NaseefVoices From The Spectrum, by Ariel and Naseef
02/01/1998 (Aprox)Institute for the Study of the Neurologically TypicalInstitute for the Study of the Neurologically Typical
25/08/2010AspergiaAspergia
01/01/2013 (Aprox)The Book of Woe, by Gary GreenbergThe Book of Woe, by Gary Greenberg
10/03/2007Light and Dark: Correcting the Balance, by Judy SingerLight and Dark: Correcting the Balance, by Judy Singer