# John Michell first imagined "black holes"

27/11/1783

But perhaps Michell’s most far-sighted accomplishment was to imagine the existence of black holes. The idea came to him in 1783 while considering a hypothetical method to determine the mass of a star. Michell accepted Newton’s theory that light consists of small material particles. He reasoned that such particles, emerging from the surface of a star, would have their speed reduced by the star’s gravitational pull, just like projectiles fired upward from the Earth. By measuring the reduction in the speed of the light from a given star, he thought it might be possible to calculate the star’s mass.

Michell asked himself how large this effect could be. He knew that any projectile must move faster than a certain critical speed to escape from a star’s gravitational embrace. This “escape velocity“ depends only on the size and mass of the star. What would happen if a star’s gravity were so strong that its escape velocity exceeded the speed of light? Michell realized that the light would have to fall back to the surface. He knew the approximate speed of light, which Ole Roemer had found in the previous century. So it was easy for Michell to calculate that the escape velocity would exceed the speed of light on a star more than 500 times the size of the Sun, assuming the same average density. Light cannot escape from such a body, which would, therefore, be invisible to the outside world. Today we would call it a black hole.

Michell got the right answer, although he was wrong about one point. We now know, from Einstein’s relativity theory of 1905, that light moves through space at a constant speed, regardless of the local strength of gravity. So Michell’s proposal to find the mass of a star by measuring the speed of its light would not have worked. But he was correct in pointing out that any object must be invisible if its escape velocity exceeds the speed of light. This concept was so far ahead of its time that it made little impression.

— Excerpt from Cosmic Horizons: Astronomy at the Cutting Edge, edited by Steven Soter and Neil deGrasse Tyson, a publication of the New Press. Published at the American Museum of Natural History website, linked below. © 2000 American Museum of Natural History.

Case Study: John Michell and Black Holes

November 27, 1783: John Michell anticipates black holes

Read the original paper by John Michell below:

On the Means of Discovering the Distance, Magnitude, etc. of the Fixed Stars, in Consequence of the...

On the Means of Discovering the Distance, Magnitude, etc. of the Fixed Stars, in Consequence of the...

Comment

Author

Info

Published in 12/04/2019

Updated in 19/02/2021

All events in the topic Scientific developments:

29/05/1919Eddington Expedition
10/04/2019 • 10:00:00The first image of a black hole is presented to the public
05/04/2017The telescope first aims at M87 galaxy center
28/04/2017Katie Bouman's TED Talk
04/11/191525/11/1915Einstein submits his papers on the General Theory of Relativity
01/01/1781Discovery of the M87 galaxy
01/01/196501/01/1967First developments of very long baseline interferometry (VLBI)
01/01/2009Creation of the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT)
27/11/1783John Michell first imagined "black holes"
22/12/1915Karl Schwarzschild solves Einstein's equations
01/01/1995Existence of black holes is confirmed
11/03/1968Shapiro time delay
01/01/1978First successful mm-VLBI observations
01/01/19941.3 mm VLBI observations between IRAM telescopes
11/01/1995 • 18:35:00Tremendous Mass Concentration in Strange Galaxy Revealed by VLBA
01/01/2003VLBI observations at 147 GHz
04/05/2011Gravity Probe B confirms frame dragging
11/02/2016LIGO first detects gravitational waves
12/04/2019Katie Bouman's talk at Caltech