Skip to content

If Neuroimaging Is the Answer, What Is the Question?, by Stephen Kosslyn


In an article of 1999 entitled “If Neuroimaging Is the Answer, What Is the Question?” the Harvard cognitive psychologist Stephen Kosslyn doubted that mental processes can ever be better understood by observing which neural sites are “activated” when subjects perform a task.

Rather, he argued, one should start with questions that inspire experimental tasks in ways that take advantage of the strengths of neuroimaging techniques. Although Kosslyn (1999) was reflecting on work done mainly since the early 1990s, his question remains as topical as ever. Over fifteen years later, and after considerable hype and groping, the neurodisciplines show evident signs of methodological and theoretical refinement. At the same time, we must still ask whether the assumptions and approaches of the neuroX are suitable for the goals, questions, and objects they define for themselves. The answer, as our case studies suggest, is that they are not.

Vidal, Fernando and Ortega, Francisco. Being Brains: Making the Cerebral Subject (Forms of Living)....

Access the full article by Stephen Kosslyn:

If Neuroimaging Is the Answer, What Is the Question?

Stephen Kosslyn is a psychologist, neuroscientist and an educator. He specialises in the fields of c...

Source of the image and caption

Stephen Kosslyn's profile at Harvard

Harvard's Kosslyn Laboratory

Watch these lectures by Stephen Kosslyn:
12. The Imagery Debate: The Role of the Brain
Minerva: A New Kind of Higher Education


No comments avaliable.



Published in 11/01/2019

Updated in 19/02/2021

All events in the topic Chap. 2: Disciplines of the Neuro:

01/01/1977 (Aprox)First use of the term NeuropoliticsFirst use of the term Neuropolitics
01/01/2002 (Aprox)Neuropolitics, by William ConnollyNeuropolitics, by William Connolly
01/01/1990 (Aprox)NeuroXNeuroX
31/03/2010Neuro Lit Crit
01/01/2007 (Aprox)fMRI: A New Research Tool, by APAfMRI: A New Research Tool, by APA
01/10/2008U.S. Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act
01/01/1924 (Aprox)01/01/1934 (Aprox)The Development of ElectroencephalographyThe Development of Electroencephalography
01/01/1991 (Aprox)Invention of fMRIInvention of fMRI